Online proctoring and the GDPR: recording and the DPIA

Online proctoring under the GDPR: recording only where the institution opts in, candidates told in advance, a DPIA before the first sitting, a named reviewer.

Online proctoring under the GDPR is not banned but conditioned: the institution has to justify each layer, document a lawful basis, tell candidates in advance and assess high-risk processing, recording above all, before it starts. On NUADU, recording is never a default; it is opt-in per assessment and supported by a DPIA template and a retention policy. What follows covers what the GDPR asks, what NUADU commits to when recording is on, how the DPIA conversation runs and who may watch the recording afterwards — for the DPO and the exam officer deciding together.

What does the GDPR require for online proctoring?

The duties it sets for any personal data, which weigh more when the people observed cannot easily walk away: a lawful basis, clear information to the people concerned, no more data than the purpose needs, no longer retention than necessary, security, an impact assessment where the risk is high, and no significant decision taken solely by automated means. Read against those duties, the recorded-review commitments on the Conduct page's invigilation model line up like this:

  • Lawful basis: documented, wherever recording is used.
  • Transparency: candidates are informed in advance.
  • Minimisation: recording is opt-in per assessment and off by default for low-stakes use.
  • Retention: a retention policy applies, and retention is configurable per data category.
  • Security: access controls are in place.
  • Impact: a DPIA template supports the institution's own assessment.
  • Decisions: a named invigilator reviews anomalies, and the system penalises nobody.

Two things are deliberately not on that list: a retention period and a storage location for recordings. The period belongs in the institution's retention policy, written for its own context, and the data posture underneath — the DPA, residency options, sub-processors — is summarised under GDPR compliance for assessment.

Recording is opt-in, configurable per assessment, and supported by a DPIA template.

Is online proctoring legal under the GDPR?

It can be. The GDPR sets conditions rather than a ban, and whether a particular set-up meets them is decided per processing activity, by the institution that runs the exam, with its DPO.

The lawful basis needs the most care. It is tempting to rely on consent, but the GDPR's recitals say consent should not be relied on where there is a clear imbalance between the person and the organisation processing their data, in particular where that organisation is a public authority (Recital 43 GDPR). A candidate who must sit the exam to progress is rarely in a position to refuse. Which basis applies is the institution's call; NUADU's commitment is that it is documented.

The second condition concerns decisions. The GDPR also protects people from decisions that rest solely on automated processing and produce legal effects for them, or affect them in a similarly significant way (Article 22 GDPR). On NUADU the system does not penalise candidates: anomalies go to a named invigilator, and the institution's academic-integrity process decides.

Are online proctored exams always recorded?

Not on NUADU. Recording is opt-in per assessment and off by default for low-stakes use, so nobody inherits it: somebody chooses it, for a named assessment, and should write down why. Where it is switched on, candidates are informed in advance.

For many assessments the question never arises. A new assessment starts with only two controls, the lockdown browser and the identity check at exam start, and for most assessments the browser-controls layer is sufficient and proportionate. A recording conversation that ends with "not for this one" is a good outcome, and the same narrow defaults sit behind the answers to common online proctoring privacy concerns. Where biometrics are not preferred, a proctor in the room or an invigilator checking government ID can stand in for the face match, so the choice to record is never forced by the choice to verify.

Do you need a DPIA for online proctoring?

For recorded review, plan on one. The GDPR makes a DPIA a precondition for processing that is likely to create a high risk for the people concerned (Article 35 GDPR), and recording candidates, often at home, during an exam they cannot skip is the kind of processing a DPO will want assessed before the first sitting rather than after a complaint.

The assessment belongs to the institution and its DPO. What NUADU contributes is the raw material — a DPIA template, data-flow diagrams, a retention policy and a sub-processor list for institutional review — part of a documentation pack that can be read as an AI vendor due diligence checklist. With those on the table, the conversation has five parts:

  1. Purpose: why this assessment needs recorded review — the stakes, the appeals it must defend; if the answer is "because the package includes it", stop there.
  2. Necessity: whether a lower layer does the job — browser controls alone, or the one-off identity match at exam start — and why it did not.
  3. Proportionality: who is recorded, for how long and who may view the footage; review on a sample basis is a legitimate design.
  4. Risks: for candidates, test anxiety, accessibility problems and the chance of a false flag; for the institution, a regulator's view of overreach and an appeal the record cannot support.
  5. Measures: the commitments above, the data flows that show where the recording goes, the retention rules and the list of sub-processors.

None of those answers can be written by a vendor; all of them can be written with the template open. If the assessment also uses a biometric step at exam start, that step raises special-category questions of its own, covered under biometric proctoring.

Who can watch an exam recording?

A named invigilator, after the fact, and whoever else the institution's access controls allow — and nobody at all unless the institution switched recording on. The system draws no conclusion from what it records.

The file then has readers beyond the reviewer, and the Conduct page names them: the DPO, the works council, the candidate's appeal and the regulator. The DPO checks access and retention against the DPIA. A works council, where one exists, reads the retention policy with employees' interests in mind. A regulator expects to trace any decision to a named human. The candidate's appeal reads the session itself, which is why every session carries a full audit trail showing what was surfaced and who reviewed it.

The decision stays outside the software. The institution's academic-integrity process makes the decision, and any challenge from the candidate runs through its defined appeals process.

→ Talk to us about your assessment workflow (30 min)