Types of online proctoring, matched to the stakes

Types of online proctoring, from a lockdown browser to recorded review, read as a ladder matched to exam stakes. Each rung is the institution's explicit choice.

The types of online proctoring usually listed are live, record-and-review and automated, but the question that decides an exam is which layers it needs. One setting for every exam is wrong twice: too much for the weekly quiz, too little for the licensing exam. NUADU's integrity model reads as a ladder of four illustrative configurations — classroom quiz, university final, professional certification, national examination — where each rung is an explicit choice by the institution, with a DPIA where appropriate, and the audit trail underneath stays the same.

What are the types of online proctoring?

Online proctoring is the supervision of an exam that a candidate sits remotely, and the industry usually sorts it into three types by who watches and when:

  • Live online proctoring: a person watches the session as it happens.
  • Record-and-review proctoring: the session is recorded, and a person reviews it afterwards.
  • Automated proctoring: software monitors the session and raises flags for a person to check.

A lockdown browser sits beside all three, as a control on the device rather than a form of supervision.

These categories answer who is watching. They do not answer how much supervision a given exam justifies, which is the question a DPO, an appeals panel and the candidate will each ask. NUADU's model is built from layers rather than types: browser controls, identity verification at exam start, optional recorded session review by a named invigilator after the fact, and optional environmental layers for the highest stakes, each configured per assessment, as the invigilation layers on the Conduct page show.

Match the integrity controls to the stakes. No surveillance theatre.

Is a lockdown browser enough for an online exam?

For most assessments, yes. NUADU's browser controls — lockdown, tab-switching detection, copy-paste monitoring and application detection, with severity configured per assessment — are the layer the Conduct page calls sufficient and proportionate for most assessments.

Is a lockdown browser the same as a proctored exam? No. A lockdown browser governs what the device can do during the exam; proctoring of any type supervises the person or reviews a record of the session. On NUADU's ladder the difference is visible at the first rung, which has browser controls and no camera at all. What a lockdown browser cannot do is confirm who is at the keyboard, which is why identity is a separate question.

For a new assessment, NUADU's defaults add one step to the browser: identity verification at exam start, a one-to-one match explained in biometric proctoring. A programme may decide browser controls alone are enough, and the identity step can give way to an alternative workflow where biometrics are not preferred. Every layer also carries a cost to the candidate — anxiety, accessibility, the risk of a false flag — so integrity settings need reading against each extra time accommodation as well.

How much proctoring does a high-stakes exam need?

More layers, each one chosen and documented, and never an inference about emotion or intent. The Conduct page illustrates the ladder with four configurations. They show how a programme might set things up; they are not accounts of named institutions.

  • Classroom quiz: lockdown browser and basic tab-switch detection. No cameras. No recording.
  • University final: identity verification at exam start, lockdown browser, optional session recording for invigilator review on a sample basis, a DPIA on file, the candidate appeals process documented.
  • Professional certification: identity verification including optional government-ID matching, lockdown browser, recorded review available, additional environmental layers configurable per the certification body's policy, documentation pack on request.
  • National examination: named invigilator workflows, candidate due process and a complete audit trail, configured to match the national programme's policy framework.

One way to pick a level adds software monitoring at the low end and a live proctor at the top. This ladder climbs differently. The bottom rung has no camera at all, each step up adds documented choices, and no rung infers emotion or intent. Recording arrives at the university final, opt-in and reviewed by a named invigilator after the fact. Government-ID matching and environmental layers arrive at certification; the environmental layers stay off unless chosen, and need both a DPIA and a documented retention policy. The national examination rung is defined less by technology than by workflow.

High-stakes exam security, on this model, means more documented decisions, not just more watching.

Who chooses the rung?

The institution — per assessment, and for organisations across jurisdictions, per region. The Certification page frames it as proportionate integrity — not a one-size-fits-all surveillance package. Every layer needs an explicit choice, with a DPIA where appropriate, and nothing above the defaults switches itself on.

Rungs can differ inside one programme. A summative final might pair identity verification at exam start and a lockdown browser with AI-assisted marking that a marker signs off, while a formative quiz in the same course runs browser controls only. Across jurisdictions, a layer can be on in one region and off in another; data residency options and works-council documentation are available on request.

Four questions help place an assessment on the ladder. What would a wrong result cost the candidate and the institution? Will the result have to stand up on appeal? Which candidates have accommodations the controls have to respect? And whose rules apply where the exam is sat? A weekly quiz answers all four lightly; a licensing exam does not.

The paperwork follows the choice: the documentation pack, DPIA template included, is available for institutional review on request. A certification body will find the ladder argued from the appeal's side on the certification exam path; a university will find where a summative exam sits in the academic workflow on the higher education assessment path. How narrow defaults answer the common online proctoring privacy concerns is covered separately.

What stays the same on every rung

Three things do not change as the stakes rise:

  • Signals stay signals: an event goes to a named invigilator, and what happens to proctoring flags is the same on a quiz as on a licensing exam.
  • Nothing about emotion or intent is inferred, on any rung.
  • The record is one record: a full audit trail per session, the same trail that runs through authoring, marking and reporting.

The rung is how a programme reaches integrity proportionate to stakes with candidate due process intact, and choosing it is the institution's job.

→ Talk to us about your assessment workflow (30 min)